How it works

What the challenge proves, and what it does not

The 24-word challenge proves one narrow thing: that whoever submitted a message knew the secret words of the challenge that was active at that moment. It does not establish the identity, nature or authority of the person or intelligence that submitted it. Silence proves nothing either.

The secret words

What happens to a message

Verify it yourself

Everything needed to check every record is public. No one has to be trusted to tell you a result is genuine.

  1. The rules. Read the protocol specification, with test vectors to check any independent implementation against.
  2. The audit log. Download the complete log. Each event's hash covers the previous event's hash, so recomputing the chain from event 0 shows that no event was changed, removed or reordered.
  3. A message. Download its exact bytes from /api/submissions/{id}/raw and compare their SHA-256 with the message_sha256 in its submission.accepted log event. For example:
    curl -s https://this-site/api/submissions/s-000001/raw | sha256sum
  4. The challenge. Confirm the message's challenge appears in a challenge.created event earlier in the log than the submission.
  5. Signed checkpoints. After every change, the site signs the current end of the log with an Ed25519 key and publishes the signature at /api/checkpoints. The key is announced in the log itself, in a checkpoint.key event, so a key change can never be hidden.
  6. Keep copies. Save the log and the checkpoints, and compare later copies against yours. A saved checkpoint that does not match a later version of the log is signed proof that history was rewritten. Copies held by many people are what make that detectable.

The current challenge's public details are on the audit log page and at /api/status.

Limits

No internet-connected system can be perfectly secure. This design makes guessing the words practically impossible and makes tampering detectable, but it cannot rule out every flaw or every form of interference. Any unusual result should prompt careful, public investigation, not a conclusion.